Awful April is upon us and people across the land are looking nervously at their bills, while trying to make some savings.

Well fear not! Because at Times Money Mentor we have LOADS of useful columns, tips and guides to help you save some money.

Check out my guide to cancelling subscriptions here. You could save over £1,000 – and no, you don’t have to give up Netflix.

Subscriptions and ongoing contracts you might have signed up to can be a huge drain on your finances. Many of the readers I speak to have had bad experiences trying to get out of contracts in the past. But don’t let that put you off. You are entitled to get out of any contract that isn’t delivering what it promised and you shouldn’t have to pay a fee to do so. 

What does the law say about contracts and subscriptions?

When you buy things, you enter in to a contract with the business or organisation. A contract is any agreement where the seller agrees to provide goods or services in return for payment. This doesn’t have to be in writing. A contract occurs when you buy in a shop, online or over the phone – even if you don’t get a formal, written contract.

The Consumer Rights Act and the Consumer Contract Regulations are the laws that protect you when you are paying for goods and services. These useful bits of legislation come in to their own when things you’ve bought and paid for don’t turn up, aren’t as advertised, are damaged or don’t work or don’t last a reasonable period of time.

But there are other laws and legal principles that can give you protection with contracts that aren’t delivering. For example, the Consumer Credit Act can help you get a refund if you’ve spent over £100 or paid a deposit on a credit card for goods or services. Then there is also the legal principle of ‘frustration of contract’ that comes in to play when a contract or subscription that isn’t providing you with what you were promised.

A subscription is any service where you pay up front or a regular fee to receive a product or service in return. Subscriptions most commonly bill you monthly, annually or irregularly.

Subscriptions sometimes vary the amount you are charged, but only if they give you advance notice or seek your permission. So if you’ve signed up to a free trial for a range of beauty products, you should be notified in advance before you are billed a specific sum if this wasn’t explicitly mentioned when your free trial ended.

New rules about ‘subscription traps’ are being introduced as part of the Digital Markets, Competitions and Consumers Act 2024. See more below.

Can a business charge me for leaving a contract early?

Some contracts are for a set duration of time. This might be an 18 month ‘fix’ on a specific price for an energy bill. Alternatively you may have agreed to a broadband and streaming deal for two years. Then there are contracts like gym memberships that lock you in to paying for a year, even if you move to another area where there’s no gym.

These contracts can charge you an exit fee for breaking the contract early. But the business doesn’t get things all its own way.

They must make you aware of the penalty for leaving the contract early. This can’t be buried in the T&Cs either as it’s a ‘key clause’ – one that should be brought to your attention when you sign up.

The same principle applies to things like non-refundable deposits. The business must make it clear to you when you might lose money you have paid in charges or penalties. If you don’t think you’ve been treated fairly, you can dispute the fees or changes.

Can I cancel a contract or subscription if I’m not happy?

There are three main reasons for leaving an agreement early:

  • The goods or services you have paid or are paying for are not what you were told they would be or are not as advertised.
  • The service has changed significantly during the contract.
  • You just don’t like the service.

In addition, two other factors can have an impact on getting out of a contract without paying a penalty:

  • You’ve paid upfront for the service so you want a full or partial refund.
  • You’re paying in instalments and want to cancel the agreement without paying any more cash.

Before you cancel a contract or subscription check the T&C’s online for any notice period required. As a general rule, it’s trickier to get out of a contact that runs for a defined period – say 12 months.  But this must have been made clear to you when you signed up. If the contract is a ‘rolling’ one, that just continues till you cancel it, contact the provider and ask them to cancel with immediate effect. If they aren’t playing ball, you can also ask your bank or credit card company to stop future payments as well.

What if what I paid for isn’t what I got?

If the goods or services you’ve paid for are not what you were told they would be, then you can ask for a refund if you’ve paid up front or to leave the contract if you’re paying by instalments.

The Consumer Rights Act says goods or services that you purchase must be:

  • Of satisfactory quality.
  • As described.
  • Fit for purpose
  • Last a reasonable amount of time

Applying the law to your ongoing contract can seem tricky, but it’s not that complicated.

Say, for example you have a leisure centre membership but you only use the pool. If the pool is closed then you are not getting the service you were told you would get so you can leave the contract without penalty or get a full refund.

The same goes for other contracts like your broadband contract. If your service provider promised you a certain download speed, but the actual service is terrible or non-existent, then they have not provided the service they should have done. Be prepared to prove it though.

Can I change my mind about a contract I’ve signed up to?

When you buy most goods or services online or offsite (not face to face), then you usually have a 14 day ‘right to cancel’ period if you change your mind. There are exceptions though, like items made to order, rental housing contracts and most things related to holidays and travel. There’s a full list on page 8 here.

What if some parts of the contract are not being provided?

Sometimes the contract that you’ve entered in to is sort of delivering, but some significant changes have occurred.

I regularly hear from readers who are unhappy with caravan parks or service contracts for their homes. These agreements cover a range of services like maintenance costs, security and upkeep of key facilities. If some of these services are not being provided, or the service has significantly deteriorated, you can argue that you are entitled to a proportional refund to reflect this.

This is the legal principle of ‘Frustration of Contract’ and it’s often invoked in disputes of this nature, most often where goods or services cannot be delivered for reasons that were not anticipated when the contract was agreed. Frustration of Contract can apply to a single event – like hiring a venue for a birthday – or an ongoing contract like a magazine subscription or a cinema membership.

Let’s say you have paid £1,200 for an annual gym membership, however, due to a flood the gym is closed for three months and there are no alternative services. You should be able to claim a £300.00 refund under Frustration of Contact as you’ve not got what you paid for. Alternatively you could pause or stop a regular subscription even if you are not at the end of the contract.

Things get a bit more complicated when services have only partially been reduced. If you have a caravan and you pay an annual fee for the plot and maintenance, you can complain if the gardening isn’t being completed, if that’s part of your contract. But you are still renting your plot and other services may be available. Under these circumstances you could potentially ask for a partial refund to reflect the fact that part of the contract isn’t being provide.

Can a business make deductions for ‘costs’?

If you are seeking a refund and citing Frustration of Contract, the business may be entitled to ask for a contribution to its costs, but only if the original contract says this is permitted.

To use the caravan park example, you can say you want to leave the contract early because you’re unhappy with the maintenance of the grounds. However, the business may charge you a small fee to reflect money it has already spent towards fulfilling the whole contract. But these charges should be set out in the contract itself.

What if the business says it doesn’t have to refund me?

Don’t be afraid to cite the law when dealing with a business that isn’t playing ball. But this can sometimes result in a rather legalistic response to your complaint.

The most effective way to resolve a contract complaint is to set out in plain English terms why you feel the business has not provided the service you were told it would. Make sure you set out what the contract promised and what went wrong.

It helps to spell out what you want to resolve the complaint too. This might be a full refund, a partial or proportional refund or simply to exit the agreement without fees or charges.

If the business says no, then don’t forget some business sectors have a free ombudsman or dispute resolution service you can go to if you are unhappy. These sectors include finance, energy and telecommunications.

However, with many other disputes, you’ll need to threaten the business with the Small Claims Court. You can read my guide about how this works here.

What if I signed up to a contract by accident or as a result of being tricked?

If you’re going through your regular payments right now, looking for things you can cancel to save some cash, you might have discovered some things that you are paying for that you never authorised or were misled in to paying for. These are often defined as ‘subscription traps’ and most commonly arise after you’ve signed up for a free trial of goods or services.

These contracts can be cancelled immediately with your bank, card provider or e-payment service. If you were misled in to taking out a contract or you didn’t authorise a business to charge you, you can ask for a full refund. The firm must be able to prove you agreed to the contract. Even if you signed up to a free trial, you can ask for your money back if you are being charged amounts that you never agreed.

What’s happening with the new law on subscription traps?

We are going to see some much tougher rules around dodgy contracts and subscriptions soon, thanks to provisions in the Digital Markets, Competitions and Consumers Act 2024.

How the new rules will work is currently under consultation, however, Department for Business and Trade Minister, Justin Madders, has said:

Reforms to subscriptions contracts and alternative dispute resolution will follow later, with subscriptions reforms not commencing before Spring 2026, at the earliest. These timelines follow commitments made in the previous Parliament, and reflect the quickest possible delivery of the reforms, while ensuring that the necessary consultation and other steps can take place.

However, retailers know that they are in the spotlight over the contracts and subscriptions they offer right now – so don’t be afraid to push back and take things further.

Featured in Times Money Mentor – Martyn James

https://www.thetimes.com/money-mentor/consumer-rights/how-to-escape-a-contract

Please share me around

Share useful info with your friends