When you spend your money, do you ever worry about getting it back if things go wrong?

Without a doubt, the best way to pay for goods or services while getting a bit of extra protection is by using your credit card (as long as you pay off the balance straight away!)

That’s because the Consumer Credit Act (CCA) 1974 gives you statutory protection if what you purchase costs between £100 and £30,000. In simple terms, if things go wrong, you could get a full refund from the card provider if the retailer isn’t playing ball.

These rights – known as ‘section 75 claims’ after the part of the legislation that gives us this power – allows you to potentially get your money back if:

  • The goods or services you’ve paid for don’t turn up.
  • The goods or services aren’t as advertised, are faulty or have been ‘misrepresented’.
  • Something goes wrong during the contract (like a badly fitted kitchen, or a gym contract that you’ve paid upfront for that gets cancelled).
  • The firm goes bust.

You can read our full guide to credit cards, the Consumer Credit Act and your rights here: [link to first article]

However, because the law is so old, there are loads of quirks, caveats and exclusions that can have an impact on whether your section 75 claim is successful. Sometimes this is because the way we pay for things and the shops we buy goods from have fundamentally changed – and the law hasn’t caught up. Other types of dispute have been around for years and are often the subject of complaints, like arguments over the quality of work by tradespeople or questionable timeshare apartment purchases.

In this article, I’ll cover the most common disputes involving section 75 claims so you can avoid them.

Has the business ‘misrepresented’ what they’ve sold me?

In order to succeed with a section 75 claim you need to demonstrate that a business has ‘misrepresented’ the goods or services you’ve purchased.

In many cases, this is obvious. If you’ve bought something and it doesn’t work, doesn’t arrive, is broken or doesn’t last a ‘reasonable’ amount of time, you can argue that you’re entitled to a refund. Usually you’ll make a claim under the Consumer Rights Act 2015 for this. You can read my Times Money Mentor guide on your rights here.

Sometimes though, the business won’t cough up, leaving you no option but to go to the credit card provider.

In most sets of circumstances, the card provider will pay out. But what is misrepresentation to one person may be unrealistic expectations to another. So things can become complicated when the situation you are complaining about is subjective.

One of the most common kinds of section 75 dispute involve the installations of kitchens, bathrooms and conservatories. Poor workmanship and damage to things like baths or worktops may be covered under a claim, but you’ll need to establish what was agreed when the contract was signed and why the business hasn’t met its obligations It’s also vitally important to explain if the business has misled you or fundamentally failed to deliver what it promised, if you want to win your claim.

Buying through third parties

I hate overly complicated terms in contracts, but we’re going to have to tackle this one head on, I’m afraid.

The ‘debtor-creditor-supplier’ is an enormously complex way of saying ‘who did you buy the goods or services from’ – and – ‘did you buy direct?’

To paraphrase the law, in order to have the protection of section 75 you have to buy the goods or services directly from the shop or supplier. If you purchase through a third party, you’re not covered by the Consumer Credit Act as this ‘breaks the chain’.

To give you an example, if you pay for tickets to a concert or event from the venue or official ticket agency (and spend over £100 on them) then you’re covered. But if you buy through a third-party ticket agency, you’re not.

When the law was introduced, this wasn’t much of a big deal. But these days, we spend a huge amount of money through ‘online marketplaces’. These businesses don’t actually supply the goods or services on their websites – they simply offer a platform where you can buy through them from the actual supplier of goods.

Let’s look at purchasing a holiday.  If you book your flights with the airline directly, you’re covered if the business goes bust or gets funny about refunding you if your flight is cancelled. But if you’ve purchased the flights through a comparison site, you’re not able to make a section 75 claim as the online marketplace does not provide the goods or services.

Because the law hasn’t really been definitively clarified when it comes to this kind of purchase, there are all sorts of grey areas. Sometimes online marketplaces are actual retailers, but might also allow other sellers to offer goods through their website.

In theory, buying from Amazon Marketplace might not be covered by the CCA (though Amazon has its own buyer/seller dispute process). In practice, these claims are often paid out by credit card companies. But not always.

The problem with PayPal and other e-payment services

The ‘debtor-creditor-supplier’ rules also cause complications with e-payment services like PayPal. Because you pay money ‘to’ PayPal and not directly in to the bank account of the seller, this breaks the chain. In the past this led to endless claims about purchases made on a credit card through PayPal being rejected.

However, things have evolved a little over the years. It’s enormously complicated, but if you use PayPal at a retailer’s checkout and use a credit card, you may be covered by the CCA. However, if you pay by logging in to your PayPal account, then you may not be covered.

Got that? No, me neither. If in doubt, pay directly with your credit card.

The other main exemptions and complications when making a section 75 claim

Goods for ‘your benefit’

This means the goods or services you purchase have to be for you, not for someone else.

So if you buy a flight on your card for yourself, you’re covered under section 75. If you buy one for another person, then you aren’t. This is because the law says the purchase must be for ‘your benefit’.

But wait! What if you are buying a gift? Isn’t that arguably for your pleasure, and therefore covered? Well… maybe! If you can make a convincing argument that the goods are for you directly or indirectly, it’s worth giving it a go. Especially if there’s an offer, like cheaper flights if you book two tickets.

Deposits

If you buy a car for £20,000 but pay a deposit of £99 on your card, the credit card company is potentially liable to refund the full £20,000 that you paid in the event of a successful section 75 claim.

Though the law suggests that deposits under £100 mean you can claim the whole value of the purchase from the card provider, many card providers will argue that it doesn’t if it’s a high value case. There’s a lot of inconsistency about how these claims are dealt with among the various card providers. You can always ask the Financial Ombudsman to look at the complaint if you feel you’ve been misled or treated unfairly.

Timeshares and other subjective purchases

You might not always be happy with what you purchase, but that doesn’t mean it’s bad.

One of the most contentious areas of section 75 disputes involve the notorious holiday timeshares.  if you buy a timeshare, you’ve technically got what you paid for even if you were subjected to a hard sell and the apartment is underwhelming.

But what if the timeshare is fundamentally not what you were sold? This might be because the location is different, there’s no sea view or the construction is poor.  These complaints are notoriously difficult to resolve as the sales process must be considered, along with making an assessment about whether this involves misrepresentation. A card provider may be allowed to argue in complex cases that the matter is ‘more suitable to be resolved by the court’.

Taking things further

As with all credit card complaints, if you aren’t happy with how a business has dealt with you dispute, you can take the matter to the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS).

The Ombudsman is a free and impartial alternative to the courts and every year they help settle hundreds of section 75 complaints. It’s really easy to make a complaint to the Ombudsman. Just get started here.

Featured in Times Money Mentor – Martyn James

https://www.thetimes.com/money-mentor/consumer-rights/credit-card-retailers-administration

Please share me around

Share useful info with your friends