“It says kind to trees sweetie… well they ‘aint made of wood, are they?!”
So said Edina Monsoon in Absolutely Fabulous about the defiantly plasticky tat she was promoting: ‘PopSpecs’.
It’s not easy being green – or living ethically. According to the Office of National Statistics (ONS) almost nine in ten (87%) of adults in the UK have made changes to their lifestyles to tackle environmental concerns or issues. But knowing how best to do this is enormously complicated.
That’s because there’s a huge range of labels, symbols, schemes and guides out there to help you with ethical purchases. But there are also a lot of misleading claims around too and inconsistent and confusing labels (supermarkets, I’m looking at you).
The trouble with ethical labels
If you want to shop more ethically, it’s helpful to have a think about what it is that you want from the products you purchase.
For example, you might want vegetables that are grown organically, but you aren’t that bothered about where they’ve come from to get to your plate. Alternatively, you might want to go fully vegan, but the high cost of some products means you’re willing to discount the various ‘fair trade’ schemes governing food production in other countries.
It’s very hard to find the ‘perfect’ ethical products because we have so many definitions of what constitutes this. There’s also a quite a bit of ‘word salad’ on many legitimate accreditation websites, making it hard to pin down what they do and how they define their core roles.
And as we’ve learned from that Absolutely Fabulous quote, shoving a label on an unrelated product doesn’t make it ‘a good thing’. Factoring in cause and effect is important too. Buying soy products to cut out meat is all well and good, but not if a massive chunk of the Amazon has been cut down to produce it.
One last warning. There’s no such thing as a standard approach to how these certification schemes work. They must factor in a vast range of factors, like the behaviour and rules of Governments in different countries, varying ethical standards, sourcing of ingredients, democracy, ensuring fair and equal pay, differences in the way goods are produced (from flowers to coca beans) and more.
Greenwashing
Greenwashing is where businesses and organisations make misleading or outright fake claims that suggest their products are in some way environmentally or ethically sound.
This can sometimes be through insidious methods, like faking or hiding data showing the businesses actual environmental impact. Just look at the number of claims against car manufactures for fake emissions data that I mentioned in my recent column [link].
With badges on products, one of the easiest tests to spot questionable claims is the ‘friendly’ rule. These greenwashing badges are on everything (along with that ‘kind to’ phrase that means precisely nothing). This term is pretty meaningless in the big scheme of things. Washing powder isn’t eco-friendly, for example.
Some examples include:
- Eco-friendly
- Ocean-friendly
- Earth-friendly
- Forest-friendly
- People-friendly (yes, this does exist)
But other words that do carry some value can be misused out of context. For example watch out for unsupported claims using these words:
- Family-owned/run
- Sustainable
- Vegan
- Green
- World/planet
- Natural
- Recyclable
That last one is key, because while many more of our products come in recyclable packaging, what can actually be recycled depends on the small print – and the rules where you live.
Those annoying but important tags on soft drink bottles that attach the caps are a reminder to us that those caps are indeed recyclable. But watch out for bottles where you may have to remove the wrapper, or the see-through window on cardboard packaging. Things change too. Pringles cans used to be notoriously non-recyclable. But now, almost all of the packaging can be. But you’ll need to check the package thoroughly.
Accreditation schemes
Here are a few examples of the best badges to look for – and the questions to ask of other accreditation schemes.
The Fairtrade logo is one of the most widely recognised certifications in the UK. It monitors a range of standards based on the product, country of origin and producers. The Fairtrade Minimum Price is the lowest amount that the producers and farmers get paid when selling through Fairtrade, which gives them a good deal. This also supports sustainability and market fluctuations (when prices go up and down). Fairtrade aims to give farmers and works control back over their livelihoods – and there’s a lot of work going on with Governments and global organisations to make trade fair too.
Vegan ranges
Not a brand per se, but worth mentioning because every supermarket has their own plant-based ranges – all with different names. Ethical Consumer has a great guide to these and what to look for when shopping for vegan products.
It goes without saying that a product that explicitly states it is vegan should not include animal based or derived products. This can lead to some startling discoveries. Vegan wine is vegan because it doesn’t use animal products to filter the final product. These filters can include; bone marrow, milk protein, fish products, crustacean shells, egg products and the big bane of the vegan’s life – gelatine.
What you’re prepared to accept or reject depends on your own principles as a vegan or vegetarian. However, you may want to look for some of the labels below, along with those of the Vegan Society and Leaping Bunny Cruelty-Free.
If you’re still a meat eater (or a pescatarian) then the RSPCA have a thorough accreditation scheme governing all farmed animals. The scheme provides consumers with assurances about:
- Quality of life/living conditions
- No battery/caged farming
- Humane slaughter techniques
- Living space
- Appropriate and responsible antibiotic use
- Sourcing and traceability
You can find out how the RSPCA assess and provide accreditation, ongoing inspections and more on their website.
One of the challenges faced by consumers is the sheer range of different accreditation schemes out there. A good example of this is finding an approved ‘organic control body’. If you want to eat organically there are eight registered organisations on the Gov.uk website. The fact that there are multiple accreditation schemes doesn’t mean that standards vary widely. But it does mean we, as consumers, will need to do a bit of research on each scheme to see if they pass our own ‘ethical tests’.
The UK’s largest organic certification body is the Soil Association. They’ve been around for 75 years and their accreditation offers a wide range of standards for many products and sectors, from the food and drink we consume to the way these products are grown, fed or processed.
It’s not necessarily how goods are produced or imported that matter. Ethics can and should extend to the way businesses treat their staff too. The Living Wage Foundation offer an accreditation service so you can be sure they are paying all of their staff enough money to get by on. The living wage is currently £12 in the UK with £13.50 for people living in London.
It’s worth noting that many businesses claim to pay the living wage, but through flexible contracts, staff may lose out on actually getting this – or aren’t paid the benefits they need to support them if they aren’t able to work. The ‘We are a living wage employer’ badge ensures you’re using a business that is following the rules.
Supermarket guide
Supermarkets still dominate our shopping baskets. Things are never straightforward though. Despite years of campaigns, threats and demands, there’s still no definitive labelling scheme for the things we consumer that fully informs us of all the facts fairly.
The ‘traffic light’ labelling system will tell you more about the following things in the product:
- Levels of fat
- Saturated fat
- Sugars
- Calories and kilojoules
The red amber and green colours give you an indication of whether that product is high, medium or low in each of these areas (apart from calories and kilojoules). But there’s a twist.
Businesses can do this by the serving – not by the total amount of the product contained in the package in your hand. So the information on a 150g large bag of crisps could relate to a standard service which could be as low as one sixth of the contents. This is exceedingly misleading – as there is no consistency around what a standard serving is. Using a calorie counting app is the only way to keep on top of this if you have a busy life.
Other terms that are misleading include:
Reduced fat: Less fat doesn’t mean healthy. As the product may still be bad for you even in small doses.
Low sodium: Many nutritionists worry about low sodium salt, as research suggest people just put more on. Using this in packaged meals further compounds the issue. Less salt is better, but the maximum recommendation for adults is 6g a day across ALL food you consume, including as an additive (about a level teaspoon).
Country of origin. This must be supplied on the food we buy, yet consumer association Which? found this was often missing or misleading.
Health benefits: Always be sceptical of these claims. Many businesses are fined every year or issued with warnings after misleading claims are made on adverts or the products themselves.
Trends: Gut health is big this year, but just including a single ingredient that ‘might’ be good for your gut doesn’t mean the thing you are consuming is good for you. Watch out for detoxing, anti-hangover and other ‘cleansing’ products where the science is most definitely not there.
Featured in Times Money Mentor – Martyn James