The reader asks:
Earlier this year we instructed an accountant to help with the sale of two of my mother’s buy-to-let properties, but we are shocked at the final bill they have provided for their services.
I don’t dispute that we have a contract with the accountancy firm, but some of the fees on the invoice are vague and I am not confident the hours they have recorded are accurate. I don’t really want to get into a legal fight, but what are my rights to dispute the bill?
Amanda, Exeter
Martyn responds:
This looks like a deceptively simple question on paper – but the reality is a little more complicated!
We have a range of laws and regulations that relate to contracts. Some consumer protection is dependent on whether the contract was signed off-site (in your home, on the internet). Other regulations have caveats that exempt the ‘sale of immovable properties’ from certain regulations. In addition, your next steps depend on what specific activities you contracted your accountant to carry out with regards to the house sale.
But don’t worry! A good starting point with any kind of contract dispute is to ask yourself if the agreement is clear about the work the business will carry out, its obligations to you and the charges they are going to bill you.
I’d start by taking a look at the agreement you signed and the quote you’ll have been given for the work. Just because a business has billed you for a service doesn’t mean it’s satisfactory or fair.
Have a think about the price that you are willing to pay – or thought you would be paying – and separate that from the charges you are disputing. If there are charges on top of this that you don’t recognise, are vague or seem unfair, ask for a full breakdown as to what they relate to and the work that was undertaken. You can also ask the accountants for proof of this.
A business should not be billing you for work that you have not authorised it to undertake. Nor should they be charging for ill-defined work, especially if it’s by the hour. Assuming that they have given you an initial quote for carrying out the job in full, you have every right to appeal excessive charges.
Accountancy is a self-regulated profession, which in this instance means there isn’t a statutory requirement for the industry to have a single complaints organisation like an ombudsman. However, there are a range of professional bodies and membership schemes that you can complain to if your accountant turns down your complaint. The Financial Reporting Council (FRC) who regulates auditors, accountants and actuaries, has a full list of these organisations on its website.
Failing that, you can always threaten them with the Small Claims Court – which is much cheaper and easier to do that you might think. And you don’t need a solicitor. Check out my guide here.
If you are considering using a professional service like an accountant’s or solicitors, I asked my fellow broadcaster and legal expert, Gary Rycroft, for his view. Gary says:
If you hire any professional service provider – like an accountant or a lawyer – make sure they are regulated or members of scheme which means they must adhere to professional standards. This includes providing transparent pricing information and letting you know if the work done is exceeding the original estimate given.
But whether regulated or not, any individual or business providing a service should keep you informed of costs and (if asked) provide a full breakdown of what is being charged. The bottom line is if you did not expressly authorise the work, they should not charge for it. A contract which lets the business bill you whatever time suits them strikes me as unfair and therefore not enforceable.