Reader’s question

I have had a comprehensive annual gas HomeCare contract with British Gas for many years. I have today received a quote proposing a 48% increase in the premium to £346.18 despite having made no claim on the policy for years. The call centre had no explanation for this at a time when inflation is circa 2%. It seems to me this is tantamount to extortion, not least because it offers no ability to increase the call out excess change above £60 to reduce the premium. Perhaps you can get a better explanation from British Gas and or OFGEM for this and why the renewal email offers no explanation. 


Martyn’s response

Home emergency and boiler cover has come under the spotlight quite a lot over the last few years.

Usually complaints are about the delay in attending and resolving the emergency, problems with repairs and damage that isn’t covered by the contracts. But in the last few months, I’ve started to hear about significant and unrealistic premium increases.

Readers who have opened their insurance renewal documents recently are likely to have taken a sharp intake of breath. Reports of price increases of up to 50% for both motor and home and contents insurance policies are not uncommon. The Association for British Insurers told the Times that motor insurance premiums alone were up by a third last year. (source).

There are lots of reasons why your insurance premiums might increase. The most obvious being if you’ve made a claim in the past year. Some of the most commonly cited reasons for price hikes with home emergency and boiler policies are:

  • Increases in the cost of repairs.
  • Increases in the cost of raw materials
  • The age of your boiler or heating system.
  • The model of your boiler (if the manufacturer no longer provides spare parts necessary to repair the boiler).
  • The number of radiators you have if you are insuring the central heating (the average in the UK is 7).
  • Costs associated with your postcode (higher crime rate, costs like the congestion charge, availability of engineers).
  • The number of claims that are made nationally each year and how much they have cost the insurer.

Some of these reasons for increases in premiums are highlighted on the British Gas HomeCare website here:

If your HomeCare renew price is different to what it was when you joined us, there could be several reasons why. Your claim history, where you live and what boiler or heating system you have can all affect your premium. Check out our HomeCare prices explained page for more on this.

It’s a source of great frustration though that insurers are under no obligation to tell you precisely why your premiums have increased so much – and requests for a detailed breakdown of the calculation is almost certainly likely to be rebuffed. So it’s not easy to establish what you have to do to cut the bill – or if they are blatantly profiteering.

The problem with the home emergency, central heating and boiler insurance market is there aren’t a huge number of players you can go to if you aren’t happy with your insurer.  This leads to many people staying put. However, there are other options out there if you are being billed an unrealistic sum.

There are a few things you might want to consider if you ask your insurer how to reduce costs.

  • Increase the excess fee for making a claim on the policy.
  • Reduce the level of your cover or take a more basic policy out.
  • Pay for a basic boiler/heating service.
  • Replace an older boiler.
  • Remove any unnecessary policy benefits you don’t need.

However, the best thing you can do to reduce your bills is negotiate – and be prepared to walk. And in this instance, that tactic has worked as British Gas has told me that they have reduced the premium by £100 in this instance.

Please share me around

Share useful info with your friends