Insurance premiums are going through the roof at the moment, with many policies increasing in cost by 50% or more.
Yet insurance is a necessity. Tempted though we may be to skimp on policies or risk it and cut them out altogether, if something goes wrong, then the cost – both financially and emotionally – can be devastating.
Insurance is designed to pay out in the event that unexpected events occur. From broken furniture to being stranded abroad, it’s a safety net that protects us from the nasty things that can lie in wait for us. But insurance doesn’t cover every eventuality. In fact there are a wide range of things that won’t lead to an insurance payout.
In this guide I’ll take a look at some of the main things that aren’t covered by some or all insurance policies.
Wear and tear
Without a doubt the single biggest reason why insurance disputes arise is ‘wear and tear’.
From the tiles on your roof to the engine in your car, wear and tear is an incredibly contentious area of insurance because it’s subjective. Over time, things that you own will reach the end of their natural life, but at what point does that become your responsibility?
There’s no real legal definition of what wear and tear entails but you might find a bit of clarity in your insurance contract when you look at the terms and conditions in detail. For example, you may find that specific maintenance requirements for things like your roof and perimeter fences are spelled out. This is a good thing, because if you follow the rules and your property is damaged, then your claim should succeed.
The problem though is many insurance contracts are vague and unclear around what the insurer considers to be wear and tear issues versus actual damage arising from a ‘claimable incident’.
As a general rule, insurers define wear and tear as ‘natural damage that occurs to contents or your property structure over time’. This means that if they believe you should have carried out repairs – and the damage you have claimed for is as a result of failing to do this – they can turn down the claim.
But they don’t get it all their own way. Unclear contract terms or unspecified definitions of wear and tear mean you can’t be expected to have understood what the insurer requires, unless you really have obviously let the thing you’re insuring fall in to disrepair!
You can rely on things like photographs of your property and invoices for work you’ve had done to dispute a claim rejected for wear and tear. A lot of these claims arise after storm damage, which means you can turn to weather data to prove that the storm was sufficiently strong to have led to the problem.
Ailments
A wide variety of insurance policies require you to disclose information about your health. Leaving aside the obvious ones, many a travel insurance claim has been declined over disputes about pre-existing health conditions.
The law around disclosure was tightened a decade ago to make both you and the insurer equally responsible, should problems arise. You must tell the insurer about any significant health conditions you have had over the last few years. This is because having these conditions could affect how much you pay for the policy – or if you are offered a contract at all. But by that same token, the insurer must also ask you clear questions so you know precisely what you have to disclose.
When it comes to what you must disclose, you need to tell the insurer:
- If you’ve had a serious condition, even if it’s in remission.
- If you’re waiting for an operation or have had one over the last few years.
- If you’re waiting for test results, from blood tests to x-rays or are being tested for something.
- If you have an ongoing condition that you are receiving treatment for.
However, some insurers have been known to ‘fish’ through your medical files when you make a claim to see if they can find anything you haven’t disclosed as a way to reject a claim. This is not allowed and the regulator takes a dim view of such behaviour. Say, for example, you forgot to disclose a trip to the doctors because of painful pins and needles (which can occasionally indicate a stroke) and they use this to reject a claim for a broken leg, then that’s fishing – because the two things are unrelated.
Some insurers ask you to disclose every trip to the doctors you’ve had over the last year or two. others, just the occasions where you had treatment or tests. Remember that the insurer must ask you all relevant questions, so if they’ve been vague or unclear, you can complain.
Upgrades
One of the most common misunderstandings about insurance is what successful claims will pay for.
Insurance is ‘like for like’ which means you will be paid a sum of money for what it costs to replace the item you are claiming for – not what it would cost to purchase the current version of that item.
Confused? You are not alone. Imagine your iPhone 12 has been nicked and you make a claim under a mobile phone insurance policy. If you claim successfully, you will be paid out what it costs to replace an iPhone 12 – not the latest iPhone 16. So that’s around £500, as opposed to the £800 for the latest model.
This can be particularly frustrating if the item is older but should still be functional. For example, a washing machine that packs in after six years should have worked for much longer, but you’ll only get a small payout because the model is largely redundant.
Things get really complicated if you’re after replacements for things like damaged kitchens. If a cupboard needs to be replaced, you might not be able to get that exact model any more. The insurance company will not pay for a new kitchen, or even replacement doors that are all uniform. You’ll get a contribution to a basic repair.
Personal belongings
Personal belongings are covered by your home and travel insurance policies… up to a certain limit. But over the last decade, the value of the items we carry around with us has increased dramatically.
Take travel insurance. Policies vary considerably, but you will find many contracts cover you for personal belongings up to a value of £1,000 to £1,500. Now have a look through your travel bag. New phone: £1,000. Tablet computer: £700. Handheld gaming console: £150. Smart watch: £400. That’s £2,250 alone. On top of that, there’ll be a limit to the amount of holiday cash you can claim for too. Oh, and just as an extra warning, if you leave your suitcase with reception when you check out, you may invalidate your insurance if the bag gets nicked or things are stolen from it!
Personal belongings may sometimes be covered by your home insurance, but there are caveats aplenty. The cover is likely to end as soon as you stray beyond the boundaries of your home. You’ll also find lots of accidents aren’t covered. This includes damaged caused by spillages, slips, rampaging children and pets, careless behaviour and DIY disasters. You can beef up your accidental damage cover but it’s not going to make every incident payable under your policy.
Oh and if you leave personal items in your car – even if they are locked away or not visible – you may find yourself disappointed when you claim for theft or damage.
Catastrophe
One last exclusion for the doom-mongers. Catastrophic events are generally not covered by insurance. This can include things like:
- War
- Terrorism
- Hostile acts
- Tornados
- Floods
- Volcanos
- Earthquakes
- ‘Acts of God’
Fair enough, you might think. But what if your holiday is cancelled halfway through because a volcano erupts or a wildfire ravages a lovely Greek island? Suddenly these disasters inch a little closer to home.
Any insurer rejecting a claim on grounds of catastrophe had better be playing fair though, as the regulator and ombudsman take a dim view of rejected claims on this basis.
Taking things further
The Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS) is a free alternative to the courts. The ombudsman deals with thousands of insurance-related complaints every year – the majority of them relating to claims.
The ombudsman takes a pragmatic view on insurance claim problems. In most cases, there’s usually a term or condition in the contract that backs up an insurer’s decision to reject or part-pay a claim. However, it takes the view that just because something is in a contract, it doesn’t make it ‘fair or reasonable’. So when considering your claim, the ombudsman might decide that a clause in a contract is unfair, or vague and too broad or open to interpretation. They may also conclude that the reasons for rejecting a claim aren’t fairly considering all the facts in the case either.
Ombudsman services have a remit to consider how businesses are behaving when they look at complaints, which means they have more consumer-focused rules than going to court, where a judge has to consider the letter of the law. So if you are unhappy with how a business has considered your claim, take it to the ombudsman.
Featured in Times Money Mentor – Martyn James
https://www.thetimes.com/money-mentor/insurance/insurance-not-cover